Hello all,
Many thanks to Rachel Howard for our notetaking this call. The minutes have been posted to the wiki and are below.
http://www.loc.gov/extranet/wiki/osi/ndiip/ndsa/index.php?title=Content_WG_April_4,_2012_Meeting_Minutes

If I missed anyone who was on the call but not listed on the attendees list, feel free to add yourself. I know some folks called in without the webex so I may have missed some names.

I encourage those of you with thoughts about the levels of preservation to chime in on the list...
Thanks!
Abbie

------------------------------------------------------
Attendees (16)

 *   Faundeen, John, Archivist | U.S. Geological Survey | [log in to unmask]
 *   Grotke, Abbie | Web Archiving Team Lead, Library of Congress, and Co-Chair of the NDSA Content Working Group | [log in to unmask] | 202-707-2833 | @agrotke
 *   Harrison, Anne | Federal Library & Information Center Committee (FLICC) | [log in to unmask]
 *   Hartman, Cathy | Associate Dean of Libraries, University of North Texas/ Co-Chair of the NDSA Content Working Group | [log in to unmask]
 *   Howard, Rachel | Digital Initiatives Librarian, University of Louisville | [log in to unmask]
 *   Kepley, David | NARA | [log in to unmask]
 *   Maes, Margaret | Legal Information Preservation Alliance | [log in to unmask]
 *   McAninch, Glen | Kentucky Department for Libraries and Archives | [log in to unmask]
 *   McGlone, Jonathan | University of Michigan Library | [log in to unmask]
 *   Moffatt, Christie | National Library of Medicine | [log in to unmask]
 *   Muller, Chris | Muller Media Conversions | [log in to unmask]
 *   Rau, Erik | Hagley Museum and Library | [log in to unmask]
 *   Reib, Linda | Arizona State Library, Archives, and Public Records | [log in to unmask]
 *   Rumsey, Abby Smith | Library of Congress/NDIIPP | [log in to unmask]
 *   Seneca, Tracy | California Digital Library | [log in to unmask]
 *   Stoller, Michael | New York University | [log in to unmask]

Report from the NDSA Leadership Meeting

Abbie and Cathy attended the meeting last Thursday and Friday. It was the first time that working group co-chairs and Coordinating Committee got together in one room for 1 ½ days. Discussion covered how things are going, what working groups are doing, where we could use support from Coordinating Committee. Abbie and Cathy shared the challenges our working group has experienced as we've grown to over 70; we're the largest, but also have fairly good attendance on our calls and with our content teams.

Outcomes of overall meeting include having press kit to guide members in talking about NDSA's purpose, plans, and accomplishments - common topics to address rather than working in silos. The Outreach Team will work on that and make it available to all members. An action list will help drive what work the Coordinating Committee can/should be doing for the organization. Watch for more details on NDSA-all listserv.

Report from the Registry Action Team

Daniel sent an update over the list. There's been a bit of concern at low number of submissions to registry, and worry that levels were stumbling block due to uncertainty or embarrassment. We've been talking about having interns help feed info into the registry, and also looking again at levels and at each item listed in the levels and expand upon them so that it becomes an internal assessment tool for deciding where we're at and what resources are needed to get to a higher level . Levels of preservation were also discussed at the NDSA Leadership Meeting last week. The Infrastructure Team was interested in looking at the levels more closely and building something around them that could benefit the membership more widely. We need to figure out where to go with that next.

Margie agreed that expansion/better description of levels will encourage more libraries to participate.

Christie suggested exploring the possibility of not making levels required, just get people to register content and over time, with assistance of interns, fill in the gaps. Levels are a stumbling block because they seem to be all or nothing - you have to meet everything in the level.

Glen reported that he's involved in another survey of state archives in U.S. with regard to preservation activities; it's even more complex in state archives to identify who's doing what, and then to go beyond that and try to figure out a standard entry is even more intensive in terms of staff.

Michael agreed that assigning levels can be a really helpful exercise, but for some institutions it's too big an exercise.

Abby Rumsey suggested identifying activities in each level as being benchmarks of excellence as a way to acknowledge progress, or things that are not relevant/priority for mission. It could just be that libraries and archives look at the set of things in each class/level and pick out the priorities that are highest for their mission and assess themselves against themselves rather than engage in a self-defeating one-size-fits-all exercise.

Tracy questioned the fundamental goal of the registry - is it more about content or about practices across the organization? Abbie explained that the original goal was to identify content, but then we had to grapple with what you mean when you say you've preserved content. Levels maybe should not be part of the registry at all, which is why there's interest in it being elevated to cross-NDSA.

Michael agreed that we shouldn't let the perfect be the enemy of the good. How easy can we make the registry so the basic info can get out there without burdening institutions with extensive self-evaluation process?

Abby reiterated that it should be possible to come up with cluster of things that characterize each level and then each institution can identify sets that apply to them at that level.

Glen suggested looking at Charles Dollar's Data Maturity levels because that's what they're using for the latest survey of state archives. It spells out 10 or 11 different categories of preservation and offers levels in each one of those categories, along with a point system. David wondered why we weren't using the TRAC checklist. Rachel pointed out that it's more complicated than the levels as we currently state them. Others said that Dollar's system is more complex than TRAC.

Abbie suggested moving this discussion to the listserv, where Kris and Daniel can provide input.

Report from the Content Teams

John (Geospatial) - Didn't meet last month. Will meet end of this month to further refine scope and areas of focus - they have more than enough input (several pages of comments), now need to figure out what to concentrate on/prioritize.

Glen (Government) - Started at beginning talking about issues with regard to electronic records risk. Seemed to be an emphasis on working with records creators to better refine what we get so that we can preserve it better. The front end was of major concern. Sense that respondents are daunted by all of the things to be concerned about - where do you start? Constructed sample document of purpose/objectives/statement but haven't yet received comments. Scheduling next meeting for end of month.

Abbie (News, Media & Journalism) - Met once and came up with categories to pursue; narrowing it down. Citizen journalism, born-digital journalism content case study that came through from UNT. Don't have another meeting set but will be working over email on those topic areas.

Christie (Science, Tech, Medicine, Mathematics ) - Met last week and identified some areas of at-risk content; still in brainstorming mode and plan to meet after using the Wiki to identify different types of data, develop case studies.

Social Sciences: Think they have met at least once but haven't heard anything lately.

Erik Rau volunteered to facilitate History. Jon volunteered to be the catalyst to get meeting going with Arts & Humanities group.

Next Meeting

Next meeting will be June 6 at 11am. There will also be an in-person meeting at NDSA meeting on Wednesday afternoon July 25, for which they're also trying to get a conference call set up. Will send out details.


~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Abbie Grotke | Web Archiving Team Lead | Office of Strategic Initiatives
National Digital Information and Infrastructure Preservation Program | Library of Congress
http://www.loc.gov/webarchiving/ | http://www.digitalpreservation.gov<http://www.digitalpreservation.gov/>
202-707-2833 | [log in to unmask]<mailto:[log in to unmask]> | @agrotke


############################

To unsubscribe from the NDSA-CONTENT list:
write to: mailto:[log in to unmask]
or click the following link:
http://list.digitalpreservation.gov/SCRIPTS/WA-DIGITAL.EXE?SUBED1=NDSA-CONTENT&A=1